Little Italy Menu (Update 2025)

Little Italy, located in Tupper Lake, NY, is a renowned Italian restaurant offering a wide range of delicious dishes. With a casual atmosphere and outdoor seating, it's perfect for groups, families, or a cozy dinner. The menu includes vegan and vegetarian options, ensuring there's something for everyone. Customers rave about the friendly service and mouth-watering meals. From chicken parm to meatball subs and cheese pizza, every dish is made with care and expertise. The pizza, in particular, stands out with its light crust, flavorful sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. Combine that with the excellent service and inviting ambiance, and it's no wonder Little Italy has been a staple in the community for almost 20 years. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Little Italy is a must for any Italian food lover.

Appetizers

Garlic Bread W/Cheese

$9.75

Doz Garlic Knots

$9.75

/ Doz Garlic Knots

$5.25

Sauce (Tomato Or Butter Garlic)

$1.25

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.95

Breaded Shrimp

$9.75

Breaded Shrimp Basket

breaded shrimp with fries

$24.00

Jumbo Chicken Wings

Order of Sauce choices: Buffalo (med/hot/xhot), bbq, buffalo honey mustard, buffalo bbq, garlic parm & golden bbq

$17.00

Sauce (Ranch Or Blue Cheese)

$1.25

Boneless Wings

lb boneless breaded wings Choice of sauce (same choices as regular wings)

$15.50

Chicken Tender W/Fries

$15.50

Bruschetta Bread

Cheesy garlic bread served with bruschetta mix (diced tomatoes, red onion, and basil in balsamic) topped with a balsamic glaze

$12.00

French Fries

$6.25

Dan Bower Sliders

Six mini sliders made with our homemade garlic knots. Choice of meatball Parmesan, chicken Parmesan or buffalo chicken with ranch

$14.50

Broccoli

Broccoli, sauteed in fresh garlic, olive oil, salt, and pepper

$8.95

Sides

Salads

Italian Antipasto Salad

Ham, pepperoni, salami, and provolone cheese on top of a large salad

$16.00

Chicken Antipasto Salad

Grilled chicken breast and provolone cheese on top of a large salad

$16.00

Roast Beef Antipasto Salad

In-house made roast beef and provolone cheese on top of a large salad

$16.00

Turkey Antipasto Salad

Deli turkey and provolone cheese on top of a large salad

$16.00

Combo Antipasto Salad

Ham, pepperoni, salami, turkey, roast beef, and provolone cheese on top of a large salad

$16.00

Caesar Salad

Romain lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing and topped with croutons, grated cheese and lemon wedge

$11.00

Caesar Salad W/ Chicken

$16.00

Caesar Salad W/ Shrimp

$17.00

Small House Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, onion & black olives

$4.50

Large House Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onion, and black olives

$8.50

Seasonal Salad

A salad special that changes with the season. Ask your server for details.

$16.00

Add Grilled Chicken

$5.00

Add Sauteed Shrimp

$6.00

Ultimate Chocolate Cake

$9.00

Tiramisu

$9.00

New York Style Cheesecake

$9.00

NY Cheesecake W/Cherries Or Strawberry Puree

$9.50

Italian Cannoli

$9.00

Desserts

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Soda Or Bottled Water

$2.85

Apple Or Orange Juice

$3.50

Pure Leaf Tea (Assorted Flavors)

$3.50

Coffee Or Hot Tea

$3.50

Hot Chocolate

$3.50

% Regular Or Chocolate Milk

$3.50

Medium Cheese Pizza

Each additional regular topping $. Each additional specialty topping $.

$15.00

Large Cheese Pizza

Each additional regular topping $. Each additional specialty topping $.

$18.00

Extra Large Cheese Pizza

Each additional regular topping $. Each additional specialty topping $.

$20.75

Gluten Free Personal Pizza

A inch round seasoned cauliflower, gluten-free crust, topped with sauce and cheese and toppings of your liking. Each additional regular to $. Each additional specialty topping $.

$14.25

Medium, Regular Pizza Toppings

Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, spinach, pineapple, tomatoes, banana peppers, jalapeno, peppers, garlic, extra sauce

$2.00

Medium, Specialty Pizza Toppings

Chicken artichoke hearts, anchovies, sun-dried, tomatoes, extra cheese, meatballs, bacon, uncured all natural ham, basil

$2.25

Large, Regular Pizza Toppings

Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, spinach, pineapple, tomatoes, banana peppers, jalapeno, peppers, garlic, extra sauce

$2.25

Large Specialty Pizza Toppings

Chicken artichoke hearts, anchovies, sun-dried, tomatoes, extra cheese, meatballs, bacon, uncured, all natural, ham, basil

$2.75

Extra Large, Regular Pizza Toppings

Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, spinach, pineapple, tomatoes, banana peppers, jalapeno, peppers, garlic, extra sauce

$2.75

Extra Large, Specialty Pizza Toppings

Chicken artichoke carts, anchovies, sun-dried, tomatoes, extra cheese, meatballs, bacon, uncured, all natural, ham, basil

$3.75

Medium White Garlic Pizza

$17.00

Large White Garlic Pizza

$20.25

Extra Large, White Garlic Pizza

$23.50

Medium, Three Cheese Pizza

White pizza with mozzarella ricotta and Romano cheese

$21.00

Large Three Cheese Pizza

White pizza with mozzarella ricotta and Romano cheese

$24.75

Extra Large, Three Cheese Pizza

White pizza with mozzarella ricotta and Romano cheese

$29.00

Medium Ranch Pizza

White pizza with ranch dressing, spinach, mushroom tomatoes and garlic

$25.00

Large Ranch Pizza

White pizza with ranch dressing, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, and garlic

$29.25

Extra Large Ranch Pizza

White pizza with ranch dressing, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, and garlic

$34.50

Medium Teds Special Pizza

Thin crust, pizza with light cheese, extra sauce, fresh garlic, basil, and tomatoes

$21.00

Large Teds Special Pizza

Thin crust, pizza with light cheese, extra sauce, fresh garlic, basil, and tomatoes

$24.75

Extra Large Teds Special Pizza

Thin crust, pizza with light cheese, extra sauce, fresh garlic, basil, and tomatoes

$29.00

Medium Veggie Pizza

Broccoli, onions, peppers, black olives, tomatoes, and mushrooms

$25.00

Large, Veggie Pizza

Broccoli, onions, peppers, olives, tomatoes, and mushrooms

$29.25

Extra Large, Veggie Pizza

Broccoli, onions, peppers, olives, tomatoes, and mushrooms

$34.50

Pizza By The Slice

Each additional regular topping . Each additional specialty topping .

$3.00

Pizza

Rolls

Pepperoni Roll

Pepperoni and mozzarella cheese

$9.50

Stromboli Roll

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese

$9.50

Calzone

Mozzarella and ricotta cheese

$10.50

Each Additional Regular Topping

$1.00

Sauce (Tomato Or Butter Garlic)

$1.25

Kilcoyne Burger

ounce burger made with local Kilcoyne grass fed, all natural beef (free of hormones and antibiotics). Served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomatoes, onion, and American cheese. Your choice of fries or salad

$18.95

Add Sauteed Onions

$0.75

Add Sauteed Mushrooms

$0.75

Add Bacon

$1.00

Add Extra Cheese

$1.00

Kilcoyne Burger

Baked Specials

Chicken Parmesan

Served with side of pasta. Choice of marinara sauce or meat sauce.

$21.00

Baked Ziti

Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$18.50

Baked Lasagna

Traditional, Italian lasagna with meat sauce, ricotta, Romano and mozzarella cheese

$19.50

Manicotti

Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$19.50

Stuffed Shells

Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$19.50

Spaghetti

Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$13.00

Angel Hair Spaghetti

Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$13.00

Spaghetti With Meatballs

Comes with two Italian meatballs. Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$17.00

Spaghetti With Sausage

Comes with two sweet Italian sausage links. Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$17.00

One Extra Meatball Or Sausage

$3.50

Cheese Tortellini

With marinara or meat sauce

$18.00

Cheese Ravioli

With marinara or meat sauce

$18.00

Fettuccine Alfredo

$18.00

Ziti Alla Vodka

$18.00

Linguine, White Clam Sauce

$19.50

Linguine, Red Clam Sauce

$19.50

Linguine, Garlic, And Oil

$14.75

Angel Hair Pomodora

Garlic, plum tomatoes & basil

$17.00

Angel Hair Garlic Oil Parmigiana

Garlic, white wine, butter & Parmesan cheese

$18.00

Pasta

Add items to any pasta

Add Chicken

$5.00

Add Shrimp

$6.00

Add Scallops

$11.00

Add Broccoli

$3.00

Add Mushrooms

$3.00

Add Artichoke Hearts

$3.00

Add Sliced Black Olives

$2.00

Add Fresh Tomatoes

$2.00

Add Spinach

$3.00

Add Sun-Dried Tomatoes

$3.00

Add Basil Pesto

$2.00

oz Extra Alfredo Or Alla Vodka Sauce

$4.00

Add Roasted Red Pepper

$3.00

Add Capers

$2.00

Substitute Gluten-Free Penne For Any Pasta

Barilla gluten-free penne pasta made with rice and cornflower. Substituted for any of our pasta dishes to make a gluten-free

$2.00

Gluten-free pasta

Hot Subs

Meatball Sub

$9.00

Sausage Sub

$9.00

Sausage And Pepper Sub

$9.00

Chicken Parmesan Sub

$9.00

Hot Roast Beef Sub

$9.00

Hot Ham Sub

All natural, uncured ham

$9.00

Philly Cheesesteak Sub

In-house made roast Beef, sauteed mushrooms, onions, and peppers. Choice of salad or fries

$14.00

Dan Bower Sliders

Six mini sliders made with our homemade garlic knots. Choice of meatball Parmesan, chicken Parmesan or buffalo chicken with ranch

$14.50

Little Italy Crispy Chicken Wrap

Crispy chicken tenders, lettuce, tomato onions, and mozzarella cheese, wrapped in our signature flower wrap. Your choice of style and choice of ranch or mayo. Served with choice of salad or fries. Style choices: Italian, buffalo, barbecue, honey, mustard, or Parmesan

$16.95

Ham Sub

All natural, uncured ham

$8.25

Turkey Sub

$8.25

Roast Beef Sub

In-house made roast beef

$8.25

Mixed Meat Sub

Ham, salami, and pepperoni

$8.25

Crispy Chicken LT

$8.25

Cold Subs

Catering

Half Tray Lasagna

Feeds - ppl

$85.00

Full Tray Lasagna

Feeds - ppl

$170.00

Half Tray Veggie Lasagna

Feeds - ppl

$90.00

Full Tray Veggie Lasagna

Feeds - ppl

$180.00

Half Tray Baked Ziti

Feeds - ppl Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$75.00

Full Tray Baked Ziti

Feeds - ppl Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$150.00

Half Tray Ziti Alla Vodka

Feeds - ppl

$80.00

Full Tray Ziti Alla Vodka

Feeds - ppl

$160.00

Half Tray Ziti Alla Vodka W/Chicken

Feeds - ppl

$90.00

Full Tray Ziti Alla Vodka W/Chicken

Feeds - ppl

$180.00

Half Tray Baked Manicotti

Feeds - ppl Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$65.00

Full Tray Baked Manicotti

Feeds - Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$120.00

Half Tray Stuffed Shells

Feeds - ppl Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$65.00

Full Tray Stuffed Shells

Feeds - ppl Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$120.00

Full Tray Chicken Parmigiana

Feeds - ppl Choice of marinara or meat sauce

$185.00

Half Tray Cheese Tortellini Marinara Or Meat Sauce

Feeds -

$75.00

Full Tray Cheese Tortellini Marinara Or Meat Sauce

Feeds - ppl

$150.00

Half Tray Cheese Tortellini Alfredo Or Ala Vodka

Feeds - ppl

$80.00

Full Tray Cheese Tortellini Alfredo Or Ala Vodka Sauce

Feeds -

$160.00

Half Tray House Salad

Feeds -

$32.00

Full Tray House Salad

Feeds -

$55.00

Half Tray Italian Antipasto Salad

Feeds - ppl

$48.00

Full Tray Italian Antipasto Salad

Feeds - ppl

$85.00

Meatballs In Marinara Sauce

$150.00

Sausage & Peppers In Marinara Sauce

$150.00

Breakfast Pizza Slice

Different options on Brunch days. Ask your server.

$5.50

Medium Breakfast Pizza

A white pizza with scrambled eggs and mozzarella cheese. Add additional toppings for $ regular and $. specialty toppings

$17.25

Large Breakfast Pizza

White pizza with mozzarella cheese and scrambled eggs. Add additional $. regular & $. specialty toppings.

$20.75

Extra Large Breakfast Pizza

A white pizza with scrambled eggs and mozzarella cheese. Add additional $. regular and $. specialty toppings.

$24.50

Breakfast Calzone

Includes eggs and choice of cheese, provolone cheddar, Swiss mozzarella or American. Add regular toppings $, add specialty toppings $.

$12.20

Regular Toppings

Sausage, peppers, onions, tomatoes, garlic, jalapenos, banana peppers, mushrooms, home fries, and spinach

Specialty Toppings

Extra eggs, chopped bacon, uncured, smoked ham, extra cheese

Fried Eggs Breakfast Platter

Includes two fried eggs, home fries, buttered sourdough bread, and your choice of bacon, ham or sausage patty

$14.00

Scrambled Eggs Breakfast Platter

Includes two scrambled eggs, home fries, buttered sourdough bread, and your choice of bacon, ham or sausage patties

$14.00

Veggie Scrambled Egg Breakfast Platter

Includes two eggs, scrambled with mushrooms, onions, peppers, spinach, and tomatoes; Home fries, buttered sourdough, bread, and choice of bacon, ham or sausage patties

$14.00

Breakfast Sandwich

Two fried eggs on choice of sourdough bread or brioche bun, choice of cheddar, mozzarella, provolone, American or Swiss and choice of bacon, ham or sausage patties. Prepared on griddle and served with side of home fries

$14.00

French Toast

Two French toast prepared on the griddle with our homemade French toast batter.

$8.00

Extra Egg (Fried Or Scrambled)

$2.00

Side Home Fries

$5.00

Side Toast

$1.75

Side Meat (Ham, Bacon Or Sausage Patty)

$5.00

Bloody Mary

Our homemade bloody Mary mix with vodka. Add additional Shrimp Skewer for $ extra

$8.50

Espresso Martini

$11.50

Irish Coffee

$7.00

Mimosa

Prosecco sparkling wine with choice of juice (Orange apple cider(seasonal), pineapple pomegranate for a blend)

$7.00

Carafe Mimosas

A mL bottle of Prosecco sparkling Italian wine served with your choice of juice

$32.00

Brunch (Sat & Sun :-: ONLY)